Santa Claus
My husband and I are on opposite ends of the spectrum where Santa Claus is concerned. I want to allow our children to believe in Santa. My husband does not.
He sees this tradition as a lie and says we are knowingly deceiving our children.
I view it as another part of the fun and magic of the Christmas season. I am confident that we can instill the knowledge of the true meaning of Christmas in our children, and not allow Santa to take away from celebrating the birth of Jesus.
Is there a WELS position on the tradition of Santa Claus Is it considered adiaphora, or a sin (lie) to allow our children to believe in the existence of this fictional character?
In some ways the custom of Santa Claus is similar to that of the Tooth Fairy. Both can be childhood games that we play with our children. It is true that Santa Claus could interfere with the spiritual life of children, if parents allow it. If they teach their children to be good in order to receive gifts at Christmas, it can give the impression that they should be good for the wrong reason.
This is not to say that it is a sin to speak of Santa Claus during the Christmas season. Yet it does point out how this custom could confuse children and blind them to the scriptural message of Christmas, especially if parents are not careful in how they present it.
You ask about how to include both Santa Claus and Christ into Christmas. Perhaps one way to incorporate both in the Christmas season yet separate Santa Claus from Christmas is to associate Santa Claus with Saint Nicholas Day, December 6th. In some cultures it is customary to hang up stockings and fill them with small gifts the night before. This would help to separate Santa Claus from Christmas Day and yet still allow some of the traditional elements of a jolly old man in a red suit to be incorporated into the Christmas season in a simple and low-key manner. That way Christmas Day can be reserved for what it is, the celebration of the Savior's birth. I know of a family that used this approach. Perhaps it is something that would work in your family.
Search the Archive
Search the Q&A archive to find answers from WELS seminary professors. Can't find your question in the archive? Submit your own.
